Table of Contents
BEST IELTS Writing Task 2, 23rd July
IELTS WRITING TASK 2
IELTS WRITING TASK 2
Young people who commit serious crimes such as rubbery or a violent attack should be punished in the same way as adults. To what extent do you agree or disagree?
SAMPLE ANSWER
In addressing whether young people who commit serious crimes should be punished like adults, it is crucial to consider various perspectives before forming an opinion. While some argue for treating young offenders with the same severity as adults, others believe in a more nuanced approach that considers their age and circumstances.
Those in favor of treating young offenders like adults argue that serious crimes warrant equal punishment regardless of age. They believe that such measures serve as a deterrent and ensure justice is served, reinforcing societal norms and safety. Additionally, they argue that leniency towards young offenders could undermine the seriousness of their actions and fail to protect the public adequately.
On the other hand, opponents of treating young offenders like adults advocate for a more rehabilitative approach. They emphasize that adolescents and teenagers are still developing emotionally and intellectually, which can affect their decision-making abilities. Punishing them as adults may not address the root causes of their behavior and could potentially worsen their chances of rehabilitation. Instead, they propose alternatives such as counseling, education, and community service that aim to reform rather than punish.
In my view, the appropriate response lies in a balanced approach that considers both accountability and rehabilitation. While serious crimes should indeed have consequences, especially to uphold justice and deterrence, young offenders deserve opportunities for redemption and reform. This could involve tailored sentencing that acknowledges their age and potential for rehabilitation, incorporating educational and therapeutic interventions to address the underlying issues that led to their criminal behavior.
In conclusion, while some argue for treating young people who commit serious crimes like adults for the sake of justice and deterrence, a more comprehensive approach that includes rehabilitation is likely more effective in the long term. It is essential to strike a balance between accountability and the potential for positive change when dealing with young offenders.
IELTS Writing Task 2